When Should You Carve Your Pumpkin for Halloween in New York? The Citizen 5 months ago Did you pick your pumpkin? Don't carve it just yet! Continue reading… Source: Hudson Valley Post Share this: Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook Share on X (Opens in new window) X What's the Earliest Date Should You Carve Your PumpkinDateOctober 17, 2019In relation toArticlesHow to Make A Pumpkin Bird FeederDateOctober 1, 2025In relation toAround the Hudson ValleyLittle-Known Hudson Valley Pumpkin Patch Named Best in NationDateOctober 10, 2022In relation tohalloween